How judging works

How this year's works are judged: the stages, the ten fields, and the schedule up to the final round.

Screening decides who is eligible. It never decides who is good. Everything after that is decided by people, in the open, with the counts visible while they move.

The stages

1

Screening — eligibility only

Who

Award office

What

Eligibility only: is the URL reachable without a login, is the Public Date in range, are the permissions given, does it breach the Code of Conduct. Not taste.

What comes out of it

Every work that passes screening goes to the first round. The office does not shortlist.

2

First round — open and free

Who

Everyone. Free, no purchase, sign-in only at Confirm.

What

The cart-model public vote. One vote per field, ten fields. This round does not pick winners; it picks who stands on the stage.

What comes out of it

Each field selects 3 to 10 works as finalists.

3

Final round — with comment and critique

Who

Award Supporters (individual partners), and the Jury

What

The final vote on the finalists, cast with a comment and a written critique attached, run live during the ceremony. A vote here is not a click — it comes with reasons, and the reasons are published with it.

The ten fields

The public vote

Open the ballot

The Jury

Jury members are drawn primarily from the community that has already been judging —the people who voted in the open round and wrote about what they saw. The office also puts forward names. For 2026 the office invites about ten people.

Nominations are open as a third route. Anyone may put forward someone other than themselves (nomination form, in Japanese; the closing date is on that page). A nomination is not a promise of appointment: the office considers it and then approaches the person directly. Whoever the route, a seat can be declined without a reason given.

They vote after the open round has closed, with the first-round result already in front of them. The window is between the close of the public vote and the ceremony.

A Jury member may look at every entered work. The ballot itself is cast from among the finalists and the recommended works: one best work in each of the ten fields. A critique is optional. After the public vote has closed, Jury members may also leave emo and comments on any work, shown as "anonymous".

"No award" is one of the choices. Deciding that a field should not have a winner this year is a decision like any other. And any field left untouched at the deadline is simply read as "no award" — there is nothing to hurry for, and nothing is lost by leaving it.

One vote per field, the same as everyone else

A Jury member holds one vote per field — the same as everyone else in the final round —and cannot veto, override, or re-open a result. No payment, partnership, or office position changes the weight of a vote.

What you take on

  • Agreement to the Code of Conduct
  • A critique with a vote is optional, and whatever is written is published. One line is enough
  • Declaring any work they were involved in, and not voting for it
  • Being named publicly as a Jury member, with a profile

What you receive

  • Credited on the site for their contribution to the award
  • Name, profile, and message published
  • Their critiques published with the result
  • An honorarium — an Amazon gift card — for a ballot completed across all ten fields with a message. Settlement against an invoice is available instead.
  • An AICU Academy 2027 licence, granted for one year

Meet the Jury →

What is not settled yet

Three things are not settled yet, and we would rather say so than imply otherwise. How the Jury's votes and the Award Supporters' votes combine into one result. Whether a recommended work that did not become a finalist is still on the Jury's ballot — the recommendation clause above says a recommendation skips screening and nothing else, so this needs to be reconciled before it is fixed. And the size of the panel and the term.

Schedule

2026-10-16 → 2026-10-26Round 3 (to Oct 26): recommended entries (no fee) and Late entries (USD 30 per work), screening results, and publication of the works going to the vote
2026-10-26The first round, the public vote, opens: one vote per field, per person. This is what picks the finalists
2026-11-13The public vote closes (21:00 JST on 14 Nov)
2026-11-18 → 2026-11-20Award ceremony — Fri 20 Nov 15:50–16:50, INTER BEE IGNITION stage IG-204 (Makuhari Messe). Afterparty 19:00–21:00 at the Makuhari Messe International Conference Hall (by invitation only)

Where each field stands

Counts only. Updated as the works come in.

FieldEntriesOn showFinalists

Write to the office

award@aicu.ai